"Cowboy Killer is certainly one of the more interesting horror films I've had the privledge of seeing. The characters are also so outrageous that you just can't help but laugh and be entertained."
- Nicky Jones, Horror Movies & Stuff"The ending left me with fond feelings toward this rinky-dink little flick and its cheerfully deranged title character."
- Mike Eshelman, Bums Corner
"Cowboy Killer has a fairly nasty exploitation flavor to it, which is a huge compliment...It's fast paced and generally light-hearted in tone."
- Tim Brayton, Antagony & Ecstasy"If you're a fan of well-written, original horror flicks with a splash of comedy thrown in, make sure to pick this one up."
- Chad Connolly, Movies Made Me Do It"This film is a low-budget classic that provides for a wickedly hilarious good time."
- Vocabulariast, Movie Cynics
"The result (of this film) is so absolutely wrong that it is absolutely right, so seriously silly that it is seriously great."
- James Teitelbaum,
Film Threat
"Another ambitious low budget flick from Cacchiotti Productions, it's a horror comedy about a psycho cowboy named Roy who embarks on a murder rampage."
- Simon Hill, Celluloid Dreams"It's a step in the development of a film career... I say 'A' for the effort... the various gore effects, though simplistic, are nicely executed."
- Pat Torfe, Arrow in the Head"There are some genuinely hilarious moments outside of the over-the-top deaths."
- Jef Burnham, Film Monthly"This movie won me over very quickly and I can't find one thing wrong with it."
- Brian Morton, Rogue Cinema"There is something oddly fascinating about the film...It is remarkably entertaining, and has a strong potential for cult film status."
- ML Kennedy, The DVD Lounge